Thursday, November 19, 2026
PrimeBulletin

Ongoing story

Is Civil Society’s Outspokenness Merely a Matter of Civic Concern?

Is Civil Society’s Outspokenness Merely a Matter of Civic Concern?

In a democratic society, it is both normal and necessary for prominent citizens to protest when allegations of injustice, irregularities, illegal occupation, attacks or violations of civil rights emerge. Raising concerns about government failures, defending citizens’ rights and speaking out about law and order can all be considered part of their civic responsibility.

Questions arise, however, when their positions do not appear consistent across similar incidents.

Two recent statements issued by groups of prominent citizens have once again brought an old question to the fore: does civil society always apply the same standards when assessing the actions of the state and political forces?

Recently, 38 prominent citizens expressed concern and anger over allegations of land and property grabbing, occupation of government-owned land, attacks and extortion allegedly carried out through political influence and the use of force in different parts of the country.

The statement warned that such incidents could contribute to a deterioration of law and order. It was signed by several well-known individuals associated with human rights, civil rights, education, research, journalism and various social movements.

Separately, 36 prominent citizens expressed concern and condemnation over an incident at the University Press Limited showroom in Banglabazar, Dhaka, where allegations of an attack and harassment of sales staff emerged amid demands to stop the sale of the book The Unfinished Memoirs.

They called for an impartial investigation, legal action against those responsible and security for publishing houses and booksellers.

Although the two statements concerned different incidents, one point was clear: a section of prominent citizens expressed concern over civil rights, law and order and the environment for freedom of expression.

But another question inevitably follows.

Are these concerns limited to recent incidents, or have similar positions been taken in response to comparable events in the past?

The question matters because Bangladesh’s recent political history has witnessed serious debates over law and order, political violence, illegal occupation, mob activity, freedom of expression and the role of political institutions.

Similar allegations have emerged under different governments at different times. Looking at one particular period in isolation can therefore make it difficult to understand the broader political reality.

The country also faces a number of complex challenges under the current government. The economic, administrative and law-and-order problems inherited from previous periods cannot be resolved overnight.

At the same time, the passage of time cannot provide immunity from accountability for crimes or irregularities committed under the current administration.

This is where the role of civil society, alongside that of the government, deserves attention.

Criticism is necessary in a democracy. But when criticism is based on consistent and broadly applicable standards, its credibility can become stronger.

If civil society is vocal against occupation, attacks, arson or mob violence under one government but remains comparatively silent when similar incidents occur under another, questions about that inconsistency are inevitable.

The political period of the past year and a half has also generated allegations and controversy.

There have been discussions about mob violence, attacks on institutions and establishments, pressure on political and personal opponents, attacks on businesses and damage to sites associated with the country’s history.

The facts, responsibility and context of each incident need to be examined separately.

But a legitimate question remains: how visible were the responses of prominent citizens to these incidents?

In particular, the swift statement by 36 prominent citizens concerning the recent controversy over the sale of The Unfinished Memoirs may naturally prompt some members of the public to ask what their positions were during other, arguably broader incidents in the past.

The attacks and vandalism involving Dhanmondi 32 and other sites associated with the Liberation War and Bangladesh’s political history have also generated extensive public debate.

It is therefore reasonable for the historical record to include discussion of how strongly civil society responded to such incidents.

There is, however, an important distinction to be made.

The absence of a public statement from an individual on a particular incident does not, by itself, establish that the person supported the incident.

Likewise, issuing a statement on a particular matter is not, by itself, evidence of a political motive.

Any assessment of the intentions or political positions of members of civil society should take into account their public statements, actions and the circumstances of the period in question.

Even so, an important chapter in Bangladesh’s political history inevitably comes into the discussion: the events of 2006–2007.

Political tensions intensified toward the end of 2006. Conflicts between political parties, street violence, blockades, political deadlock and disagreements over the national election became increasingly severe.

On January 11, 2007, a state of emergency was declared and a military-backed caretaker government assumed power. The developments surrounding that period subsequently became widely known as the “1/11” episode.

During that period, a section of civil society played an active role in efforts to address the political crisis.

The role of another section subsequently became the subject of considerable political debate. Some viewed their involvement as an attempt to resolve a severe political crisis, while others argued that it contributed to a tendency toward governance from outside the conventional political process.

That historical experience is one reason why significant political activity by civil society naturally attracts scrutiny in Bangladesh.

However, comparisons between the past and present require caution.

The circumstances of 2006–07 were not identical to those of the current political period. The individuals, institutions, political dynamics and international environment were also different.

It would therefore be unreasonable to conclude, solely on the basis of similarities, that the two periods are part of the same political project.

Yet the question remains: is the recent activism of civil society driven solely by civic concern, or is it also connected to broader political developments?

That question cannot be answered through speculation.

It requires an examination of the content of their statements, the timing of their interventions, their positions on comparable issues in the past and the broader political context in which they are speaking.

In a democratic state, the government cannot remain beyond accountability. At the same time, criticism from civil society is not itself beyond scrutiny.

Civil society has the right to question the government, just as citizens have the right to question the consistency of civil society’s own positions.

Bangladesh has experienced many periods of political crisis. Mass movements against elected governments, political deadlock, violence, emergency rule and prolonged periods of non-elected governance are all part of the country’s political experience.

Whenever a new crisis emerges, people will naturally compare current events with what they have experienced in the past.

For now, the most important priorities are maintaining law and order, preserving political stability, protecting citizens’ rights and ensuring impartial investigations and legal action in cases of alleged wrongdoing.

If civil society speaks out on these issues, it can play a constructive role in a democratic environment.

Its role, however, is likely to carry greater public credibility when its standards remain clear and consistent toward all governments, political forces and forms of wrongdoing.

Because citizens do not only want to know what happened.

They also want to know whether the language of protest remains the same when similar things happen to different people, under different governments and in different political circumstances.

The two recent statements, therefore, are not merely protests over two specific incidents. They have also revived a broader debate about the role of civil society in Bangladesh, the consistency of its positions and its responsibilities during periods of political uncertainty.

More